Your search results

Search Homes

Search current realMLS listings by city and price. For bedrooms, bathrooms, property type, preferred features or help comparing locations, share your search preferences with a Hi agent. Planning the purchase too? Compare ownership costs or explore mortgage options with Hi.

← Back to listings
4 NELMAR Avenue, St. Augustine, FL 32084 — photo 1 of 251 / 25
Active
$589,900
4 NELMAR Avenue, St. Augustine, FL 32084
Listing brokerage: WATSON REALTY CORP
2 beds · 2 baths · 1,440 sq ft · $410 / sq ft · 41 days on market
Facts & features
Property typeSingle Family Residence
CountySt. Johns
Year built1973
Lot size0.15
SubdivisionNelmar Terrace
Garage spaces2
Stories1
CoolingCentral Air, Electric
MLS number2168169
Days on market41
Request a tour with a Hi agentPlan this move with MoveReadyExplore a Hi OfferStart a mortgage application
Market value & public records

Estimated market value

$658,000

Estimated range: $577,000–$739,000

RentCast automated estimate based on available comparable sale listings and property data; retrieved Nov 17, 2026. This is not an appraisal, offer, or guarantee of sale price.
Comparable sale listings
$959,0008 Park Ave, Saint Augustine, FL 320842 bd · 3 ba · 1,426 sq ft
$494,50018 Ocean Ave, Saint Augustine, FL 320842 bd · 3 ba · 1,408 sq ft
$570,00017 Dufferin St, Saint Augustine, FL 320842 bd · 2 ba · 1,049 sq ft
$679,00086 Masters Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 320842 bd · 2 ba · 1,343 sq ft
$519,00022 Bernard St, Saint Augustine, FL 320842 bd · 2 ba · 1,176 sq ft
Payment calculator

Estimate your monthly housing cost

Adjust the assumptions to explore a payment. Values stay in your browser and are not submitted to Hi.

Estimated monthly total: —

Illustration only, not a loan offer or quote. The latest cached Freddie Mac 30-year fixed weekly average rate is used by default and is editable; Taxes and HOA are prefilled from IDX or RentCast where available; CDD is prefilled from MLS when available. Homeowners insurance starts at 1% of list price annually. Confirm whether CDD is already included in the tax figure to avoid double-counting, and verify all estimates with providers.
Neighborhood

Market snapshot · ZIP 32084

Sale-listing statistics for this ZIP code, not a property-specific appraisal.

Median asking price$364,500
Average asking price / sq ft$308.60
Average days on market97
New sale listings this month62
ZIP asking-price trend$389,900$360,0002025-12 · $379,9002026-01 · $375,0002026-02 · $370,0002026-03 · $375,0002026-04 · $375,0002026-05 · $379,9002026-06 · $389,9002026-07 · $387,5002026-08 · $385,9002026-09 · $375,0002026-10 · $360,0002026-11 · $364,5002025-122026-11
ZIP asking-price trend
Source: RentCast ZIP-level sale listing data. Trends may have gaps where sample sizes are limited; rental listings are excluded.

Overview

Currently operating as a 5-star Airbnb, this beautifully updated & renovated home is located in highly desirable Nelmar Terrace & has never flooded. Sun-filled living spaces feature brand-new LVP flooring throughout, creating a fresh, inviting feel. The chef-inspired kitchen opens seamlessly to the living & dining areas & offers abundant cabinet & counter space, & stainless-steel appliances. The oversized owner's suite features a spacious sitting area, home office or gym. Both bathrooms have been recently renovated & feature large, step-in showers. A well-appointed guest bedroom is conveniently located across from the updated second bath. Notable upgrades include a NEW ROOF installed 6/26/25 w/ transferable warranty, updated electrical service w/ buried lines, & a dedicated interior laundry area. The extra-large detached two-car garage is a rare find & includes its own electrical sub-panel, providing exceptional storage & vesitile work space. This turnkey property offers style, flexi bility, and investment potential in one of St. Augustine's most sought after neighborhoods! Walk to historic St. Augustine and enjoy restaurants and attractions and a quick drive to great beaches!!!

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Verify all details independently. © 2026 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.

Compare Listings